Skip to content
3D Printing Certification

LLNL researchers use X-ray imaging to mitigate defects in metal 3D printed parts


Scientists at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL), SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory (SLAC) and Ames Laboratory are researching X-ray imaging to examine metal parts during the laser powder bed fusion process. The research paper is part of a partnership between the laboratories to identify the causes of defects in metal 3D printed parts and understand how those flaws can be mitigated.

In order to carry out the project, LLNL researcher Nick Calta and his team have designed a portable diagnostic machine capable of probing the metal 3D printing certification process using X-ray imaging. The machine ultimately helped provide researchers with new insights into the metal additive manufacturing certification process. “A vast majority of diagnostics use visible light, which are extremely useful but also limited to analyzing the surface of the part,” explained Calta.

“If we’re going to really understand the process and see what causes flaws, we need a way to penetrate through the sample. This instrument allows us to do that.”

Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory researchers (from left) Phil Depond, Nick Calta, Aiden Martin and Jenny Wang. Photo via LLNL.
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory researchers (from left) Phil Depond, Nick Calta, Aiden Martin and Jenny Wang. Photo via LLNL.

DOE funded laboratories investigate laser powder bed fusion process

The multi-year partnership between the laboratories is funded by the Department of Energy (DOE)’s Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) Advanced Manufacturing Office. Both SLAC and AMES are DOE laboratories, with LLNL also primarily funded by the federal agency. The collaboration between the laboratories is an offshoot of the DOE’s National Laboratories Big Ideas Summit (BIS).

The DOE’s BIS is an annual event intended to nurture collaboration and strategic technical planning in the national laboratory complex. The collaborative project established between the three laboratories reflects the BIS, with SLAC contributing its X-ray technology, and Ames Laboratory providing expertise in powders, metals and material science. “It’s a really nice team because each partner brings a strength,” said Tony Van Buuren, deputy division leader for S&T in LLNL’s Materials Science Division.

“The team is building a capability that is somewhat unique and providing information you can’t get any other way. Together we’re bringing in the diagnostics, spinning in science and spinning out the ability to look at new materials.”

The Big Ideas Summit. Photo via DOE.
The Big Ideas Summit. Photo via DOE.

Identifying pores in metal AM parts using X-ray imaging

The portable diagnostic machine is designed specifically to observe and probe the melt pool during the laser powder bed fusion process. The melt pool is the area where the laser makes contact with the metal powder, enabling fusion and producing the layers that form the 3D printed part. It was assembled in situ, and proved difficult to construct due to the aggressive timeline of the research project, according to Calta. In order to make sure the instrument operated according to the intentions of the research, the LLNL team were required to transport it to SLAC. It was then fitted with SLAC’s ‘synchotron’, which was necessary to create high energy X-rays to investigate the samples.

Using the machine at the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource at SLAC, researchers were able to successfully observe the dynamics of the melt pool beneath the surface. It provided meaningful data on a combination of imaging and X-ray diffraction, which helped researchers observe and understand how the metal solidified during laser powder bed fusion, a key determiner of a part’s strength.

“Success would be learning more about the physics in ways that let us modify the process to avoid defects,” continued Calta. “So far we’re getting promising results. We want to continue to optimize the instrument and apply it to different material systems. We already have a big body of knowledge based on optical data, this lets us branch out and complement that knowledge.”

Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) 3D printing certification in an EOS machine. Photo via EOS
An example of the laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additive manufacturing certification process on an EOS 3D printer. Photo via EOS

Ibo Matthews, LLNL physicist, has said that the ability to observe the layer formation process of the melt pool and the comparison of X-ray images to simulations, has confirmed previously made predictions. These forecasted that a laser’s path, heat buildup and gas plumes created by the laser can establish defects in the printed part, like pores, which can cause cracking in the part when put under stress. Compiling the knowledge of defects with modeling and detailed experiments can potentially help to accelerate improvements and confidence in metal 3D printing certification, according to researchers.

Although the collaboration is still in its early stages, Calta has said that the researchers have quickly begun mapping out the formation of pores and identifying information on cooling rates already. With the X-ray imaging diagnostic machine, it is expected that the research will provide an improved understanding of laser…